Help Arrives at Christmas: The Gospel Hiding Inside Our Favourite Holiday Films

A small brick church in a snowy, run-down city street at night, its open doors pouring warm golden light onto the snow beneath a single bright star

Every year it happens on cue. The nights get busier, the shopping centres start playing carols, and the streaming services fill up with Christmas films. This year one of them has broken out of the pack. Tyler Perry's The Gospel of Christmas landed on Netflix on 11 November and, within two days, was the most-watched movie on the platform in the United States. The story is simple: a preacher named Isaac inherits his late father's struggling church in New York, the building is facing foreclosure, the neighbourhood needs help, and Isaac is no longer sure he has the faith to save any of it. Add a choir full of gospel legends and a Kirk Franklin soundtrack, and you have a hit.

Critics have called the plot earnest and a little thin. Fair enough. But I want to ask a different question: why does this kind of story work at all? Why do we keep making, and watching, films where a broken person in a broken place is rescued just when all seems lost – and why does it so often happen at Christmas?

The shape of a Christmas story

Think of the films that have become part of the season. In Dickens' A Christmas Carol, a cold, lonely man is shown his past, present and future, and wakes on Christmas morning a new creation, promising, "I will honour Christmas in my heart, and try to keep it all the year." In It's a Wonderful Life, George Bailey stands on a bridge on Christmas Eve believing the world would be better without him, and is shown how many lives his own small life has held together. In The Gospel of Christmas, a tired pastor wrestles with grief and with prayers he thinks have gone unanswered.

The pattern is remarkably consistent. The setting is dark: winter, debt, grief, a failing town or a failing church. The hero cannot save himself. Help arrives from outside, often in an unexpected or humble form. And the rescue is not just a change of circumstances but a change of heart. The man who is rescued becomes generous, the despairing man discovers he is loved, the doubter finds his voice again.

That is not a random set of story beats. It is the Christmas story itself.

Light in a dark place

Isaiah wrote centuries before Bethlehem: "The people who walked in darkness have seen a great light" (Isaiah 9:2). St John opens his Gospel with the same picture: "The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness has not overcome it" (John 1:5). When that light finally came, it did not come to a palace. Luke tells us Mary laid her newborn son in a manger "because there was no place for them in the inn" (Luke 2:7). God entered the world through the back door, into poverty, in an occupied province, at night.

St Paul describes it as a kind of self-emptying: Christ "emptied himself, taking the form of a servant, being born in the likeness of men" (Philippians 2:7). The Catechism gathers up the reasons the Church gives for why the Word became flesh: to save us by reconciling us with God, so that we might know God's love, to be our model of holiness, and to make us "partakers of the divine nature" (CCC 457–460). Notice that last one. The Incarnation is not only rescue from outside; it is transformation from within. That is exactly why our favourite Christmas films end not with a cheque in the mail but with a changed heart.

St Athanasius, writing in the fourth century in On the Incarnation, used an image that could almost be a film pitch. When a great king comes to live in one house of a large city, he said, the whole city is honoured and protected because of him, and bandits no longer dare to attack it. In the same way, the Son of God took up residence in one human body, and the whole human race was lifted by his presence. A rundown neighbourhood with the King living in it is no longer a lost cause.

Tolkien's word for the turn

J.R.R. Tolkien had a name for the moment every good Christmas film builds towards. In his essay On Fairy-Stories, he coined the word "eucatastrophe": the good catastrophe, the sudden joyous "turn" when, against all expectation, things come right. He argued that this turn gives us a glimpse of joy beyond the walls of the world. And then he made a striking claim: "The Birth of Christ is the eucatastrophe of the history of Man. The Resurrection is the eucatastrophe of the story of the Incarnation."

In other words, the reason the turn moves us so much in fiction is that it is true somewhere. The story we keep telling at Christmas is an echo of a story that actually happened.

"Isn't it all just formula?"

Here is the strongest objection, and it deserves a fair hearing. A sceptic might say: these films are simply commercial formula. Rescue-at-the-last-minute plots exist because they sell, not because they point to God. Humans love underdog stories in every culture. And the timing of Christmas itself, the objection often goes, was borrowed from older winter festivals like the Roman Saturnalia. So the "gospel echo" is really the other way round: Christianity is just one more version of a universal human myth.

There is truth in parts of this. Rescue stories are found far beyond Christianity, and studios certainly make Christmas films because audiences watch them. Historians also still debate how 25 December came to be chosen; some point to Roman solar festivals, while others argue early Christians calculated the date from the traditional date of the Annunciation. The honest answer is that the date is not what the faith rests on.

But notice what the objection actually concedes: that human beings everywhere long for a rescuer who comes into the dark from outside and sets things right. C.S. Lewis, who once thought exactly as the sceptic does, came to see this longing not as evidence against Christianity but as evidence for it. In his essay "Myth Became Fact" he wrote, "The heart of Christianity is a myth which is also a fact." The old stories were not lies the Gospel copied; they were hungers the Gospel fed. If God made us for himself, we should expect our stories to keep reaching for him, even when the storytellers do not mean them to. As St Augustine prayed, "our heart is restless until it rests in you" (Confessions 1.1).

And there is a difference the formula cannot explain. Christmas films ask us to suspend disbelief for two hours. The Gospels ask nothing of the kind. They name an emperor, a governor and a census (Luke 2:1–2), and they stake everything on events that witnesses claimed to have seen. A formula is something we invent. The Incarnation, Christians claim, is something that happened to us.

When the church in the film is your own

What I appreciate about The Gospel of Christmas, whatever its flaws, is that it puts a struggling church and a doubting pastor at the centre of the story. Plenty of us know that feeling. Many parishes are shrinking, ageing or stretched thin, and plenty of faithful people carry private doubts into the pews every Sunday. The Christmas message is not that faith makes those things disappear. It is that God chose to come precisely into places like that: small, poor, overlooked and tired.

So as the Christmas films roll out over the next few weeks, enjoy them. Have a laugh at the predictable plots, and maybe shed a tear at the turn. But when you feel that lift at the end, ask where it comes from. It may be the oldest story in the world tapping you on the shoulder.

What is the Christmas film that moves you most, and what do you think it is really pointing to? I would love to hear your pick in the comments.

– Noah Marshall

Popular posts from this blog

The Architecture of Resilience: A Comprehensive Biographical and Sociological Analysis of Nick Vujicic

The Mathematical Apologist

The Good News